How to Find the Right Critique Group or Partner for You

by Dyfnaint | via Flickr

Today’s impermanent station is from Brooke McIntyre of Inked Voices, a site wherever writers shop successful small, backstage online groups.

---

Finding a penning group aliases partner is simply a batch for illustration dating. There’s an constituent of searching and an constituent of matching. You’re looking for group you tin stock a portion of your imaginative aforesaid with, for group you want to walk clip on, for group who tin thief you go a stronger writer—a people aliases community. So a bully fresh is important.

More than ever before, location are galore options for uncovering a group, wherever you unrecorded and immoderate your schedule. There are ample groups and small, successful personification and online. And each group has its ain feel.

Below I’ll stock immoderate things to see erstwhile looking for those typical someones. Then, I’ll stock immoderate places to look for partners.

What to Look For successful a Partner aliases Group

One of nan things I find astir rewarding astatine Inked Voices is helping group lucifer pinch penning groups. Here’s what I’ve learned astir what makes for successful partners.

1. Shared Direction, Similar Stage

When penning partners stock a direction—such arsenic a extremity to publish, a desire to support up a accordant penning practice, aliases a dream to make writer friends—they’re often looking for nan aforesaid benignant of committedness to each other.

When penning partners person comparable acquisition writing, learning astir craft, aliases publishing, they’re starting from a akin place. An knowledgeable writer successful a group of newbies whitethorn get frustrated. On nan different hand, having a fewer caller writers successful a much knowledgeable group is usually fine. Stage matters much for nan group arsenic a whole, and each personification brings unsocial talents that whitethorn guidelines retired much than their experience.

Here are immoderate questions to inquire yourself:

• What is your penning experience?
• Do you person worldly to stock now? Or are you looking for a group that will thief motivate you done nan finish?
• Do you person a accordant penning practice?
• Where do you want to go? Why are you willing successful this group?
• What other are you doing to meet your penning goals? Do you publication blogs for illustration this 1 aliases books connected craft? Have you taken classes aliases attended workshops?

Where you are coming matters. But wherever you want to spell and what you will do to get location is much important erstwhile looking for a lucifer for nan agelong haul.

2. A Workable Pace

Pace is simply a tricky one. It seems simple: really often do group members taxable worldly aliases meet up? But really it’s astir a equilibrium of your ain clip and power and equilibrium wrong nan group. The gait should move pinch capable oomph that you make progress. However, a accelerated gait tin overwhelm; a slow 1 tin consciousness unchallenging aliases for illustration group are not writing. Either utmost leads to group quitting nan group.

What’s your ain penning pace? Many overestimate really overmuch penning we tin realistically produce, particularly successful nan excitement of a joining a caller group. I’ve been guilty. Plus you person to see really overmuch clip you person to springiness thoughtful feedback. For some questions, err connected nan blimpish side.

• Think astir really overmuch penning you produced this period and successful nan erstwhile 2 months.
• Count connected spending astatine slightest 30 minutes reference and commenting connected each submission—more for longer ones. Ballpark nan clip committedness by multiplying clip to critique by number of group members (don’t see yourself) by submissions per personification per month.
• For in-person groups, gait equates to really often members meet. Consider really often each members of nan group tin make nan logistics work.

Ideally, location is simply a equilibrium betwixt giving and receiving feedback. Sometimes group person spurts of productivity and nutrient more. Or life happens and they nutrient less. It often useful retired complete nan agelong haul. If members commencement to consciousness for illustration they are critiquing but not writing, things person fallen retired of alignment. Prepare to beryllium flexible; a gait that useful for an full group each nan clip is unlikely.

3. People Enjoy nan Writing and Feel Comfortable Critiquing It

Most of nan clip successful a penning group is spent reference and giving feedback connected different people’s work. It should beryllium fun. Maybe you won’t emotion everything. But if you for illustration most, you’ll bask nan reference and go invested successful nan stories.

It’s difficult to know that you’ll for illustration nan activity until you really spot it, but location are immoderate bully proxies. What do you for illustration to read? What are your favourite genres, books, and authors? When a writer says she likes Ursula K. Le Guin, definite group travel to my mind. When I spot a short fabrication writer who likes Jhumpa Lahiri, different group of group comes to mind. Some groups measure this fresh by requesting a sample of your writing.

I spot galore groups shape astir genre, specified arsenic speculative fiction, free verse poetry, aliases imaginative nonfiction. Broader groups, for illustration women writers, aliases “anything short,” are awesome for group who constitute and publication crossed genres and who bask critiques from a assortment of perspectives.

If you participate successful a broader group, see uncovering a buddy successful your genre, particularly if your genre has peculiar conventions aliases rules. Picture book writers deliberation astir page turns, enigma writers present nan criminal early and quietly, romance ends pinch optimism. Your buddy tin springiness you a nudge erstwhile you stray retired of bounds.

So, How Do You Go About Actually Finding One of These Groups?

Writing Associations

Writing associations are a awesome spot to find groups aliases partners. Meet group successful personification done location meet-and-greets, acquisition events, aliases by volunteering pinch your section chapter. Let your section cognize you are looking for a group; it will astir apt want to help.

Some associations person an online action to find partners. The Society for Children’s Book Writers and Illustrators has nan “Blueboards,” a backstage forum wherever members tin station nan benignant of group they are looking for. People reply, and past members whitethorn shape nan group arsenic they like. American Christian Fiction Writers has a ample online critique organization called Scribes, done which members often find smaller groups of critique partners. Similarly, The Women’s Fiction Writers Association has a critique group matching work which puts members together into groups of four. Romance Writers of America has an online critique partner matchup hunt for members. Members opt successful to beryllium searchable erstwhile mounting up their profile. People willing successful uncovering partners hunt subgenres and location for matches.

Conferences and Retreats

Conferences are a awesome measurement to enactment energized, consciousness nan powerfulness of a large community, and study much astir craft. They’re besides a awesome spot to meet critique partners (thank you, Lisa, for starting a speech pinch Elena and maine astatine SCBWI nationalist successful 2014!) Conferences merge group pinch a communal interest, beryllium it shared genre, location, aliases both. Plus, conference-goers are often astatine nan aforesaid stage. Many person astatine slightest 1 completed manuscript, and they whitethorn moreover beryllium getting feedback connected it astatine nan conference.

Here are immoderate ways to meet critique partners astatine conferences:

1. When chatting pinch people, mention your liking successful starting a group. Even if that personification isn’t interested, he aliases she tin link others to you.
2. Start a sign-up expanse (ask nan convention organizer to make judge it’s okay first).
3. Tell nan organizers you’re looking for a group, and spot if they person advice.
4. Participate successful critique roundtables. If you bask different people’s work, attack them afterward and spot if they mightiness for illustration to speech material.

Shaw Guides has a thorough listing of penning conferences. Writing associations and Facebook groups are besides bully sources for leads. Google brings up plentifulness of options: effort typing successful nan sanction of your genre aliases region positive writers retreat aliases writers conference. Here is simply a write-up connected immoderate of nan awesome retreats.

Meetup

Depending connected wherever you unrecorded and your genre, location whitethorn beryllium penning groups organized done Meetup. These groups typically meet successful personification and are organized by 1 aliases much individuals successful your area. To find a group, hunt position apt to look successful a group’s explanation for illustration writer, author, poet, writing, writing group, picture book, novel, aliases screenplay.

Check retired each Meetup’s “About us” tab to find retired nan thrust of nan group. There are workshop-style, networking, and “shut up and write” groups (where group clack distant and stock activity time). Drill down into erstwhile meetings, their location, and attendance. Some Meetups look very large—here successful New York, location are Meetups 300, 500 and 1,000 group strong—but existent information is smaller. It could beryllium a accordant halfway of 10 people. Or you whitethorn find different group be each time. Message nan group admin pinch your questions aliases be a gathering to find retired whether it’s a fit.

Participate successful a “Mo”

• NaNoWriMo is nan large fish, but galore different Mo’s person sprung up connected nan heels of its success. Beyond getting you writing, a Mo is simply a awesome measurement to find immoderate organization and possibly a semipermanent penning group.
• Camp NaNoWriMo takes spot successful April and July and is unfastened to each writers, including poets, short fabrication writers and children’s writers, successful summation to novelists. Writers group their ain 10,000-plus connection count extremity for nan period and participate successful a twelve-person online cabin. Cabinmates spot each another’s connection count progress, cheer successes, and commiserate erstwhile things get tough. If you emotion your cabin, get their interaction accusation and support moving together aft nan arena ends.
• NaPoWriMo challenges poets to nutrient 30 poems during National Poetry Month each April.
• Storystorm, held successful January, began arsenic a measurement for children’s writers to brainstorm image book ideas but has since evolved to encompass a broader scope of writing.

Other Networking Opportunities

To find section groups, effort networking successful your community. Chat up section bookstore unit aliases your savvy librarian. Scan organization bulletin boards aliases station to your vicinity listserv. There whitethorn besides beryllium location networking groups successful your area, for illustration nan New York City Writers Network, that attraction connected connecting writers. Ask astir aliases hunt nan sanction of your area positive writing community, writing group, aliases writers networking.

To web for online partners, effort societal media aliases cheque retired immoderate of nan online forums. There are galore Facebook groups for writers, immoderate group up for nan intent of manuscript swaps. Join them to find a group of like-minded writers. After you’ve oriented to nan group, station that you are looking for partners and spell from there. To find a group, hunt wrong Facebook aliases see what Facebook suggests for you—this useful champion if you person penning accusation successful your profile.

Use a Twitter arena for illustration Dan Koboldt’s #SFFPit (for subject fabrication and imagination writers) to look for partners. If you for illustration nan person’s pitch, scope retired to nan writer and commencement a conversation.

Finally, location are galore online forums for writers to cheque retired for networking and critique, including Absolute Write, The Women’s Fiction Writers Association’s Critique Forum Facebook group, The Mystery Writers Forum, and myWritersCircle.

Online Critique Sites

Many online critique sites usage technology, specified arsenic inline commenting, critique deadlines, backstage chat boards, notifications, and writer profiles, to heighten nan penning group process. Most of these sites are backstage to protect individuals’ work. Writers tin participate successful site-wide critique communities, ample backstage groups, aliases mini ones, depending connected nan site.

Online groups typically tally connected a credits aliases points system, wherever credits are utilized to taxable activity and earned for giving critiques. Sometimes, nan credits strategy besides useful successful conjunction pinch a queue strategy (basically, your submission waits successful statement for its turn).

Critique sites mostly pull superior writers willing successful improving their craft. Check retired nan exertion and organization to spot if it’s a fresh for you.

All Poetry is a penning organization for poets. Poets whitethorn station their activity to nan sitewide organization for comment, and premium members tin commencement their ain penning critique groups. Basic memberships are free, metallic are $5.95/month, and golden are $14.95/month. Read much astir memberships.

Critique Circle is an established penning organization that uses a queue system. Members usage credits to taxable activity to nan queue and person credits for stories they critique. New members person entree to a abstracted newbies queue for their first fewer submissions arsenic they study nan ropes. Premium members tin create backstage critique groups pinch their ain queue, perfect for groups utilizing nan site. There are basic, premium and premium golden memberships, each pinch its ain benefits. Premium memberships are $10/month, $34/6 months aliases $49/year. Preview nan tract by checking retired their YouTube tutorials.

Critique.org is nan genitor tract of nan well-known Critters.org site, which offers critique for subject fiction, fantasy, and scary writers. Critique.org evolved from Critters to dispersed its celebrated format to different genres, including literate fiction, mystery, romance, and more. Critique.org genre groups are ample and run via email based connected a queue system. When a writer’s submission reaches nan apical of nan queue—usually astir a month—the manuscript is emailed to nan group for feedback. Members are expected to critique astir 1 manuscript per week. The tract is free and runs connected donations.

Inked Voices is simply a tract for writers looking for smaller critique groups and for pre-existing groups looking for a spot to tally their penning group online. It includes private, invitation-based groups, video lectures connected craft, and a sitewide forum. Members hunt individual aliases group profiles to find partners and besides get individual assistance matching. I besides periodically facilitate three-month adjacent workshops geared towards members caller to penning groups aliases still looking for nan correct fit. Memberships are $10/month, $75/year (discounts for pre-existing groups). Check retired nan demo connected our homepage aliases see a screenshot tour.

The Next Big Writer offers a assortment of backstage and nationalist penning groups of varying genres and sizes, arsenic good arsenic online penning classes and an yearly contest. Groups tin beryllium nationalist aliases backstage and each tin elite whether to usage nan site’s points system. Authors power who tin spot their work, whether tract connections, group members, aliases a broader audience. Basic memberships are free and see information successful 1 group, while premium memberships let information successful up to 10 groups. Premium memberships are $8.95/month, $21.95/quarter aliases $69.95/year. See a demo connected their About Us page.

Scribophile is simply a critique organization pinch groups, contests, a adjuvant blog, and a chat forum. Writers taxable activity to nan site-wide organization aliases to backstage groups utilizing points. Either way, activity is backstage to nan site. Groups are mostly larger and genre-focused and location are galore options available. Premium members get further devices for formatting documents and showcasing their work, and tin station much than 2 useful astatine a time. Free basal memberships. Premium memberships are $9/month aliases $65/year. Read their FAQ.

Writers Café is simply a ample organization of writers that includes contests, groups, critique, and a forum. The tract is wholly free. Read their FAQs.

Writing.com is simply a ample organization of online writers pinch a sitewide organization for critique, nan expertise to subordinate and create groups, and galore contests. Members tin shop their manuscripts successful an online portfolio and tin power privateness of their submissions, whether backstage to nan tract aliases publically viewable. There are five levels of membership, including a free plan.

Review Communities

Some of nan large publishers besides person online communities. These sites are mostly much astir getting reviews and nan anticipation of patient discovery. The highest-rated submissions get publication by nan publishers, sometimes starring to manuscript requests and/or book deals.

• Underlined (Penguin Random House)
• Swoon Reads focused connected YA romance (Macmillan)

Wattpad is akin to nan sites above, but is not affiliated pinch a peculiar house. Wattpad writers often station their activity successful chapters, and immoderate person built ample scholar followings successful nan process, starring to book deals for immoderate members.

Email and WordPress Groups

Many email penning groups run done Yahoo Groups. Try respective searches to get a database of candidates to explore.

Hunt for different email and WordPress groups by Googling; scan beyond nan first fewer pages of results. Internet Writing Workshop members subordinate a critique database for manuscript exchange; information requirements are listed connected nan site. The Desk Drawer is an email group that shares submissions and critique connected penning exercises posted each week. NovelPro is for superior writers who person completed a 60,000+ connection novel. Swirl and Swing is simply a backstage WordPress-based critique group for poets.

Final Thoughts

There are galore paths to a penning group. Prepare to put successful immoderate elbow grease into your search. See what strikes you and springiness it a try. If it’s a fail, effort again. It usually takes immoderate persistence to find nan correct group. But erstwhile you do, it’s gold.