Elon Musk’s X ban dispute with Brazil takes toll on local crypto community

Brazil’s prohibition connected societal media tract X has deed nan Brazilian crypto organization hard, arsenic galore successful nan blockchain manufacture — from researchers to influencers, fundraisers, convention organizers and accelerators — exertion nan tract arsenic a captious intends of connection and promotion.

On Aug. 30, almost 22 cardinal users were cut disconnected from X successful Brazil, astatine that long Brazilian Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes recovered X to beryllium allowing and promoting misinformation related to erstwhile Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro.

The prohibition has caused Elon Musk’s societal media institution to suffer 1 of its biggest markets.

X users successful different countries arsenic of April 2024. Source: Statista

Victor Cioffi, maturation head and halfway squad personnel of crypto accelerator Solana Superteam Brasil, told Cointelegraph that X is nan astir celebrated societal media level among Brazilian youth, arsenic it is chiefly secondhand for posting informal random thoughts. 

However, nan crypto manufacture uses it arsenic a master instrumentality to beforehand their companies and ideas, and astir importantly, it’s nan portal done that they tin prosecute alongside nan world crypto audience: 

“X is secondhand to scope nan world audience, truthful if oneself don’t person X for belonging to you trading strategy, it’s for illustration losing an arm.”

Cioffi explained that nan prohibition connected X successful Brazil forces oneself to take betwixt being an outlaw to pass and beforehand belonging to you merchandise to nan outer world, aliases abiding by nan rules and scrambling to link connected different societal media platforms.

Brazilian crypto manufacture loses assemblage and revenue

A study conducted successful 2024 by cryptocurrency value locator CoinGecko recovered that X is nan starring societal media level for crypto users to stitchery precious intel and is by acold their preferred societal media site.

For influencers and crypto firms, X offers a ample assemblage for launching campaigns and provides an easy introduction constituent for caller imaginable clients. 

João Ferreira, co-founder and CEO of Brazilian decentralized finance (DeFi) app Picnic, told Cointelegraph that his institution had already mislaid “half of its reach” arsenic X was their superior connection platform. 

Ferreira said that “as a founder, successful position of fundraising and getting successful interaction alongside VCs and different influential individuals, it decidedly hurts rather a bit.”

Most group get their crypto news from X. Source: CoinGecko

Casta Crypto, a Brazilian crypto pedagogue and contented creator, told Cointelegraph that X was his primary transmission for communicating alongside caller projects and initiatives and his mean for engaging alongside his assemblage done regular interactions.

After nan ban, he said that his assemblage has efficaciously dropped by astir two-thirds, arsenic nan different 3rd of viewers travel from YouTube. 

A celebrated Brazilian crypto influencer, that person wished to stay anonymous to debar imaginable repercussions, told Cointelegraph that she “cannot slumber for respective days” because she felt that nan “treasure” of her assemblage mightiness beryllium successful jeopardy. X was her astir salient societal media level successful position of engagement.

Recent: 6 things nan US needs to enactment competitory successful crypto, according to execs

Furthermore, arsenic an influencer, she said that she was opening to consciousness lonely “as it’s a way to link alongside people.”

She said that nan X prohibition had sent her paranoia levels done nan roof, joking that she had begun to deliberation nan recent suspensions of Brazilian crypto influencers’ Instagram accounts could person thing to do alongside nan X ban. 

The anonymous influencer told Cointelegraph that “everyone is trying to find replacement solutions.” 

She observed a surge successful respective platforms, including YouTube Community posts, Substack posts, Instagram, Farcaster, Threads, Nostr, and Bluesky, that has added much than 1 million caller users since nan X ban.

Casta Crypto admitted that he has tried alternatives, but “so far, it was not imaginable to replicate these dynamics [of X] anyplace else.”

He lamented that nan Brazilian organization “had not only mislaid a important magnitude of assemblage but of coordination and a highly precious network effect”.

Crypto conferences and DAOs suffer

ETH Floripa intent return spot successful February 2025; however, she is worried that, little than six  months distant from nan event, “any entree to X could beryllium captious astatine this stage.”

“We’ve mislaid important information specified arsenic arena engagement levels, imaginable sponsors, and willing partners [...] lacking X; ourselves suffer nan network effect wrong nan Web3 space.”

Decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs) are world and decentralized organizations that require integer devices to coordinate effectively.

Zschaber said that her business Blockful, that deals straight alongside DAOs, has mislaid their main transmission of communication. She says that nan patient had mislaid entree to basal accusation from stakeholders, partners and different DAOs.

While DAOs typically exertion Discord for coordination, Zschaber said that awesome updates are often shared connected X successful existent time.

It’s not that they're wholly successful nan dark; “it’s astir nan practicality of accessing information,” making nan process slower and clunkier.

This deficiency of real-time entree to important accusation tin besides impact mundane Brazilian crypto holders.

The anonymous influencer noted that galore crypto protocols exertion X to update users connected imaginable information breaches and hacks. Brazilian victims of hacks for illustration that of DeFi staking protocol Ether.fi wouldn't person alerts successful real-time, expanding nan likelihood of being scammed, she told Cointelegraph.

As nan business worsens and nan prohibition continues, galore person debated moving overseas to debar these issues contempt galore not wishing to time off nan country. Ferreira said he’s “actively looking to move retired of Brazil,” arsenic nan X prohibition “was benignant of nan past straw for me.”

Brazilians statement X ban

The statement complete nan X prohibition is still raging successful Brazil. Some person formed nan communicative arsenic a struggle betwixt billionaires and nan sovereignty of nan Brazilian state, during others spot it arsenic an rumor of free speech. 

— Marcel van Hattem (@marcelvanhattem) August 31, 2024

Joao Victor Archegas, laminitis of nan investigation group connected integer constitutionalism and contented moderation ModeraLab and coordinator astatine nan Institute of Technology and Society, explained to Cointelegraph that nan state of reside has respective limitations successful accordance alongside nan Brazilian Constitution of 1988. 

Archegas mentioned that nan state of reside “can beryllium legitimately restricted to protect different arsenic important basal rights.” 

He said that nan halfway statement successful Brazil is if nan prohibition aft X refused to comply alongside Brazilian rule is proportional.

While immoderate outlook nan prohibition arsenic disproportionate and an outright onslaught connected nan state of speech, Archegas said that “one cannot suffer show of nan truth that X forced its way retired by outright defying nan Brazilian Supreme Court successful divers cases.” 

Archegas admitted that nan Supreme Court’s decisions tin and should beryllium criticized, but they “do not constituent to immoderate signs of deliberate, wide governmental censorship successful nan country.” Like different countries, Brazil is learning really to header alongside immoderate of nan antagonistic externalities of platforms for illustration X, said Archegas.

Recent: Polymarket users kick of mysterious Google login wallet attacks

Although location is simply a morganatic interest astir judicial overstepping — particularly astatine that long fining those caught utilizing a VPN to entree X — each companies operating successful Brazil request to exertion nan disposable ineligible avenues to activity redress. Defying nan court’s authority is simply a non-starter.

While nan statement continues, galore fearfulness X intent ne'er return to its original authorities owed to self-censorship. Crypto Casta believes that “self-censorship is simply a increasing inclination successful nan full of nan Western world since nan emergence of nan cancel civilization and its weaponization arsenic nan unwritten norm for regulating reside and acceptable world views.”

For Crypto Casta, nan problem is that erstwhile progressive voices situation unwritten norms and nan fearfulness of “cancellation” is nary longer a deterrent, nan authorities intent measurement successful to enforce these norms. 

Ferreira is pessimistic, believing that X whitethorn ne'er return to its original authorities and believing that astir group won’t care.